The real choice

A non-US group opening an office in San Francisco or Los Angeles will have a company that is subject to California law in most of the ways that matter: California employment law, California payroll taxes, California franchise tax and California's securities notice requirements. The choice is whether the entity is formed in California or formed in Delaware and then qualified in California as a foreign corporation. Forming in Delaware does not avoid California; it adds Delaware.

That is worth doing when the Delaware corporate statute and courts matter: when the subsidiary will raise US venture capital, grant stock options under a plan that US investors will scrutinise, be sold to a US acquirer or be reorganised into a US parent. It is not worth doing when the subsidiary will remain wholly owned by the foreign parent, employ staff and sell services, and never issue equity to anyone else. For that company a California corporation (or LLC) is cheaper and simpler.

Formation and qualification compared

  • Delaware corporation. Certificate of incorporation filed with the Division of Corporations (state fee from US$109, varying with authorised stock; expedited service available), registered agent with a Delaware street address, no residency requirements. Then a statement and designation by foreign corporation filed with the California Secretary of State, a California agent for service of process, an initial Statement of Information and registration with the Employment Development Department and the Franchise Tax Board.
  • California corporation. Articles of incorporation filed with the Secretary of State (US$100 under the published schedule; check the authority), an agent for service of process who is a California-resident individual or a registered corporate agent, a Statement of Information within the first period and annually thereafter (US$25), and the same employment and tax registrations. No second state.
  • LLC in either state. A single-member LLC owned by the foreign parent is the simplest operating vehicle where no equity will be issued: Delaware certificate of formation US$110 or California articles of organisation US$70, a Statement of Information every two years in California (US$20), and the US$800 California annual LLC tax plus the gross-receipts LLC fee. The LLC is disregarded for US tax but is a corporation for many foreign parents' purposes; take advice on the parent's side before choosing it.

All fees are as at the review date; check the authorities.

Annual cost and filings

A Delaware corporation qualified in California carries two annual cycles. Delaware: annual report (US$50) and franchise tax (minimum US$175 under the authorised shares method or US$400 under the assumed par value capital method) by 1 March, plus the registered agent's fee. California: Statement of Information annually in the registration month (US$25) and the franchise tax with the return, at least US$800 after the first year. A California corporation carries only the California cycle. A Delaware LLC qualified in California pays Delaware's flat US$300 annual tax by 1 June and California's US$800 LLC tax plus the LLC fee.

The difference in cash is a few hundred dollars a year plus the agent; the difference in administration is a second calendar, a second penalty regime (Delaware's US$200 penalty plus 1.5 per cent monthly interest) and the need to recalculate the Delaware franchise tax each year to avoid the authorised-shares default. Groups that run several US subsidiaries find the Delaware cycle easy to systematise; a group with one subsidiary may not.

Governance and corporate law

Delaware's General Corporation Law is flexible on board structure, written consents, indemnification and the terms of preferred stock, and the Court of Chancery decides disputes quickly without a jury; investors' standard documents assume it. California's Corporations Code is more protective of minority shareholders: cumulative voting cannot be eliminated in a closely held company, shareholders have broader inspection rights, and the statute applies some of its provisions to foreign corporations whose business and shareholders are mostly in California (the quasi-California rules), which can reach a Delaware corporation anyway.

For a wholly owned subsidiary none of this matters much: the parent is the only shareholder, decisions are by written consent, and litigation between shareholders is not in prospect. It begins to matter at the first outside investor, the first option grant to a US employee and the first discussion of a US parent flip. A group that can see those events within two or three years should form in Delaware from the start; one that cannot should form in California and accept that a later conversion or merger into a Delaware corporation is possible, at a cost.

Employees, equity and securities law

Either entity employs Californians under California law, with its rules on non-competes (unenforceable), overtime, pay transparency and termination. Stock options granted to California employees must comply with California's securities exemption for compensatory plans (a notice filing under Corporations Code section 25102(o)) regardless of where the company is formed, and the plan must meet the conditions that attach to that exemption. Delaware formation is therefore not a way around California's rules on equity; it is a way of making the equity itself conform to the documents US investors expect.

Where the US subsidiary's employees will receive equity in the foreign parent rather than in the subsidiary, as is common for Asian and European groups, the choice of US entity is almost irrelevant to the equity; what matters is the parent's plan, the US tax treatment of the award and the subsidiary's payroll reporting. GoGoTrust runs the US reporting for parent-company awards from the group cap table, and LegalMatrix prepares the US sub-plan.

Wyoming and Nevada, and what GoGoTrust recommends

Wyoming and Nevada are sometimes proposed for their low fees, absence of state corporate income tax and privacy of ownership. For a holding company with no US operations they can serve; for an operating subsidiary in California they add a third state with no benefit, because California taxes the company on its California activity whatever its state of formation and the privacy is lost on qualification. GoGoTrust does not form operating subsidiaries there unless the business is actually located there.

The default GoGoTrust recommendation for a foreign group is: a Delaware C corporation qualified in California if the subsidiary will raise US money, grant equity or be sold in the United States within a few years; a California corporation or a single-member LLC if it will remain a wholly owned sales, service or engineering subsidiary. Formation starts at US$1,200 in either case and the Essential maintenance tier at US$2,400 a year covers the state filings, registered agent and calendar for both states where two are involved. Tax elections for the parent's benefit are advised on by US CPAs in the Magellan Global Group network. Figures and rules are as at the review date; check the authorities.