Two forms, one Companies Act

The Companies Act of 2005 created the godo kaisha (GK) as a Japanese limited liability company alongside the kabushiki kaisha (KK), the joint-stock company. Both give their owners limited liability, both are taxed as corporations (there is no pass-through election for a GK in Japan), both can be formed with capital of JPY 1 and a single owner, and both are registered with the Legal Affairs Bureau. The differences are in governance, formation formalities, publicity and the ability to issue equity, and those differences map closely onto the question of who will own the company in five years.

JETRO's comparison, which this guide follows, lists the same categories: capital, number of investors, liability, officers, term of office, meetings, transfer of equity and taxation. The sections below take them in the order that matters for a foreign founder or parent.

Governance and officers

  • KK. Owned by shareholders, managed by directors. A small KK needs at least one director and may have a board (three directors plus a statutory auditor or committee). Directors of a KK with share transfer restrictions serve terms of up to ten years, after which re-election must be registered; the annual shareholders' meeting is mandatory and approves the financial statements.
  • GK. Owned and managed by its members. All members are executive members unless the articles say otherwise, and at least one is the representative member; a corporate member appoints an individual executing officer. There are no terms of office, no mandatory meetings and no statutory auditor; decisions are taken as the articles provide, by default unanimously for changes to the articles and by majority of executive members for business decisions.

For a wholly owned subsidiary, GK governance is lighter: no annual meeting, no director re-election registrations, no risk of being treated as dissolved for failing to register for twelve years. For a company with several owners, KK governance is clearer: shares, votes, a board and a meeting are what Japanese counterparties and courts understand.

Formation cost and formalities

  • Articles. A KK's articles must be certified by a Japanese notary, who also receives a declaration of the beneficial owner; the notary's fee is scaled to capital (check the authority). A GK's articles are signed by the members without notarisation. Electronic articles avoid the JPY 40,000 stamp duty for both.
  • Registration and licence tax. 0.7 per cent of capital in both cases, with a minimum of JPY 150,000 for a KK and JPY 60,000 for a GK.
  • Timeline. JETRO cites two to three months for a KK and about two months for a GK from fixing the company profile, with a foreign corporate shareholder; the registration itself takes one to two weeks in either case. The difference is the notary step.
  • Capital payment. Both require the capital to be paid before registration. A KK's capital is paid into an incorporator's or director's Japanese bank account and evidenced by a statement; a GK's may be evidenced by a receipt from the representative member. Neither solves the problem of a founder without a Japanese account.

The saving on a GK is therefore the notary fee, JPY 90,000 of registration tax and a few weeks. For a parent company that will own the subsidiary indefinitely, that is a reasonable saving; for a founder who will raise money, it is small relative to the cost of converting later.

Publicity, transfers and equity

  • Public notice. A KK must publish its balance sheet each year after the annual meeting, by the method in its articles; a GK has no public-notice obligation. Foreign groups that prefer not to publish subsidiary figures often choose the GK for this reason alone.
  • Transfers. KK shares are transferable, subject to board or shareholder approval if the articles restrict transfers, which they almost always do for a private company. A GK member's interest can only be transferred with the unanimous consent of the other members, and a new member must be admitted by amending the articles.
  • Stock options. A KK can issue stock acquisition rights (shinkabu yoyakuken), including tax-qualified stock options that meet the conditions of the Special Taxation Measures Act. A GK cannot issue stock options in the ordinary sense; equity incentives in a GK are limited to admitting members or contractual phantom arrangements, neither of which qualifies for the tax-qualified regime.
  • Investment. Venture investors invest in KK shares, usually preferred classes created by the articles; a GK has no shares to prefer. A GK that wants to raise equity converts to a KK first.

Perception, visas and banking

The KK is the form Japanese enterprises, banks, landlords and recruits recognise. Large foreign groups have made the GK respectable as a subsidiary form, and Japanese counterparties no longer blink at a GK with a well-known parent. A start-up with an unknown founder is a different case: a GK may be read as provisional, and recruits may ask why there are no options.

The Business Manager status of residence for a founder looks at the company's capital, office and business plan rather than its form; JETRO's comparison lists the same capital condition for both. Banks apply the same due diligence to both forms but are more familiar with the KK's documents. Conversion from GK to KK is a registration procedure (an organisational change with public notice to creditors) that takes about two months and costs registration tax; it is routine but it is a project, and option grants cannot be made until it is done.

A decision rule and GoGoTrust service

Choose a GK when the company will be a wholly owned subsidiary of a foreign parent, will not issue equity to employees or investors, and the parent prefers not to publish the subsidiary's balance sheet. Choose a KK when the company will have more than one owner, will grant stock options, will raise money, will sponsor a founder's residence status or will sell to Japanese enterprises under its own name. Where the answer is uncertain, choose the KK: the additional cost is modest and the conversion later is not.

GoGoTrust forms either (from US$3,200, through licensed judicial scriveners, with tax notifications by a certified tax accountant) and maintains either (Essential tier from US$4,800 a year, covering the tax cycle, registrations, the KK public notice and the calendar). Where a GK later needs to become a KK, GoGoTrust runs the conversion and LegalMatrix prepares the KK articles, the stock option plan and the Japanese-language resolutions. Registration taxes and fees are as at the review date; check the Ministry of Justice and the National Tax Agency.